1991
Commonwealth Transp. Comm’r v. Hurley
Virginia Circuit Court
24 Va. Cir. 19
At just compensation trial, Commissioner’s expert testified the amount of the take was $110,705, with no damage to residue. Landowners’ expert testified the take compensation was $135,992.50 and the damage to the residue was $129,045. Commissioners awarded $135,000 for the easement taken and $125,000 for damage to the residue. Commissioner moved to set award aside, and court granted motion and a new trial was ordered. Landowners’ expert had impermissibly based his opinion on speculative future events. Landowners moved for reconsideration, and court reinstated award as Commissioner had not made a contemporaneous objection, and had thereby waived any objection to the testimony or amount of the award.
Summary prepared by Judge Jonathan Apgar, 23rd Judicial Circuit in Virginia, for the William & Mary Property Rights Project, Marshall-Wythe School of Law, William & Mary ©2019.
Back to Case Finder Main Page
Volume One Indexes:
To Case Name Index
To Topic Index
To Date Index
To Code Section Index